[Taken] Leaving feedback in response to Recruitment

Not open for further replies.


Landscape Designer
Super Moderator
Community Operator
Jan 11, 2008
Responses to recruitment threads are very much welcome and you can choose to either endorse a player's request for membership or, alternatively, leave a negative review of their play style.

Both types of response are bound by the same rules as any other sub-forum.

Criticism of another player is not breaking any rules, although in an ideal world this criticism should be constructive.

The only rule you should bear in mind when considering a negative response to a recruitment thread is:

  • Challenge other's points of view and opinions, but do so respectfully and courteously. Be civil and constructive, not ignorant and rude.
This is the only rule I can foresee being applied to negative responses to recruitment posts, but you'd have to say something fairly derogatory to have your post removed.

By all means leave a bad review of someone's playstyle (or lack thereof) but don't be cruel/attack the character of that person.

Examples of both:

"I've played on X number of occasions with Bloggsy. He is not a very active player, he does not work well as part of a team, his communication is lacking/none-existent and he's rarely online"

"I played with Bloggsy last round. He's basically a bit of a retard, avoid him at all costs because he sucks".

Basically, its not difficult to say something negative whilst still being nice/reasonable about.
Not open for further replies.